November 19, 2026
The cottage at 35 North Shore Road was built in 1950 and has 656 square feet: two bedrooms, one bath, a screened porch facing west over Perkins Pond, and a 25-foot dock. It sits on 0.18 acre with 80 feet of frontage. In November 2024 it sold for $430,000. This August it came back on the market at $550,000, dropped twice in September, and on November 5 went under contract at a list price of $495,000.
The square footage on that listing is small, and the sewer hookup and new roof are useful but ordinary. What the buyer is mostly paying for is the lot, one of the small shoreline parcels cut from old farmland around the pond nearly a century ago, on a shore that was largely built out by the 1980s. Read with that in mind, the town's sales record for Perkins Pond is a price list for frontage, and the house on each lot changes the price only within a narrow range.
The Town of Sunapee publishes its recorded sales each year and codes waterfront parcels separately. Its file covering April 1, 2025 through March 27, 2026 lists two waterfront sales on roads that ring Perkins Pond. Add the 2024 sale of 35 North Shore Road and this fall's contract, and the pond's recent history looks like this:
| Address | Date | Price | Lot size | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 35 North Shore Rd | Nov. 7, 2024 | $430,000 | 0.18 acre | Recorded sale |
| 65 Piney Point Rd | June 4, 2025 | $590,000 | 0.16 acre | Recorded sale |
| 60 Burma Rd | Aug. 29, 2025 | $800,000 | 0.359 acre | Recorded sale |
| 35 North Shore Rd | Nov. 5, 2026 | $495,000 list | 0.18 acre | Under contract |
On Lake Sunapee, the town's waterfront sales over the same April 2025 to March 2026 window ran from $2.3 million at 1100 Lake Avenue in Georges Mills to $3.95 million at 93 Lake Avenue, $4.995 million on Scotts Cove Road, $5.215 million on Burkehaven Lane and $9.5 million on Jobs Creek Road. Perkins Pond is in the same town, with the same tax rate, and the Perkins Pond Watershed Management Plan puts it less than two miles from Sunapee Harbor. Distance doesn't explain a gap of millions of dollars. The lots do.
The Perkins Pond Watershed Management Plan, dated March 2026, includes a history of how the shore was divided, drawn from Sunapee Historical Society research. Until 1900, five farms surrounded the pond. Over time they changed hands and were broken into smaller lots that were sold for cabins. The first cottages went up in the early 1900s. Owners packed in their supplies on foot because there was no road.
In the 1930s about ten cabins were built, nearly all of them by Newport families who worked in the mills. Lots of roughly 100 feet by 100 feet on the west shore, on former cow pasture where Mary's Road runs today, sold for one hundred dollars each. By the 1950s about 60 structures lined the shoreline, and by 1987 about 20 more had been added. As of 2021 the plan counts 103 cottages on Perkins Pond, 21 of them occupied year-round.
The lot sizes in the table come straight out of that history. The parcels at 0.16 and 0.18 acre are the size of a 1930s cabin lot, and they match the 100-by-100-foot pieces cut from pasture and woodlot. Lake Sunapee's shore holds estates on several acres. The parcel behind the $9.5 million Jobs Creek Road sale is 7.3 acres. The two lakes were divided for different buyers in different eras, and the prices still follow those original divisions.
The same plan includes a long-range projection of where future building in the watershed would go. It counts 145 existing principal buildings and projects room for 102 more, most of them in forested or agricultural land in Sunapee and Croydon, away from the water. The plan describes the shoreline as already the most densely built part of the watershed.
For a buyer, the growth the plan projects is back in the woods. On the shore, the cottages on North Shore Road, Piney Point Road and Burma Road compete mostly with each other. Prices on the pond depend on how many buyers want one of the existing shoreline lots in a given year, and on what each lot comes with.
It also explains how prices vary along the pond. In the town's record, the $210,000 difference between Piney Point Road and Burma Road comes with a parcel more than twice the size. When every lot is small, a little extra land is a large share of what makes one parcel different from the next.
The fall listing at 35 North Shore Road shows how far a house can move a lot's value. The 2026 listing describes new flooring, stainless appliances, updated heating, a tankless water heater and a new roof with a transferable warranty. At $550,000, the asking price was $120,000 above the 2024 sale. The listing was cut to $520,000 on September 9 and to $495,000 on September 23. The contract came on November 5, about 73 days after the cottage first went on the market.
At $495,000, the list price was $65,000 above the November 2024 sale and still $95,000 below what a slightly smaller lot on Piney Point Road brought in June 2025. The town has no closing price yet, since the cottage was under contract as of mid-November. Even so, the list price history narrows the range. The cottage did not go under contract at $550,000 or at $520,000, and it did go under contract once it was listed at $495,000. At $495,000, the listing works out to $755 per square foot. That figure makes more sense as the price of 80 feet of frontage with a small cottage on it.
For a seller on the pond, the lesson from this fall is about timing. The listing went on the market on August 24, late in the boating season. It found a buyer in November after two reductions. A Perkins Pond cottage priced as a share of its frontage, with the improvements as a modest premium, matches the pattern in the town record.
Sunapee's assessing office lists a 2025 tax rate of $10.55 per $1,000 of assessed value and a 2025 assessment ratio of 80%. The last full revaluation took effect April 1, 2023. In April 2025, Selectboard materials noted that state review data for an upcoming 2026 assessing audit indicated market appreciation since the 2023 revaluation.
On Perkins Pond, the gap between assessment and price shows up in the town's own ratio column. Piney Point Road sold at a price its assessment covered at 81%, and Burma Road at 82%, both close to the townwide figure. In November 2024, 35 North Shore Road sold at a price its $311,100 taxable value covered at 72%, which means the buyer paid more for the lot than the 2023 valuation suggested. The listing shows 2026 gross taxes of $3,246 for the cottage. A buyer comparing Perkins Pond assessments with asking prices should expect the asking prices to be higher. This is general market information, not tax or financial advice, and anyone weighing a specific property should confirm the figures with their own attorney, accountant or lender.
On a pond where every lot is small, owners share the water more closely. Homes within 300 feet of the sewer lines around Perkins Pond were moved off septic and onto public sewer between 2013 and 2015. The cottage at 35 North Shore Road is on public sewer. The 2026 plan names 14 stormwater sites and 44 shoreline parcels with moderate or high phosphorus impact, and it recommends stormwater work and continued monitoring. The Perkins Pond Protective Association, which formed in the 1950s as the Perkins Pond Land Owners Association, worked with the town on the plan. Our summer post on the Perkins Pond ramp covers what that work looks like from the water.
For a buyer comparing lakes, this matters as much as price. With 103 cottages counted around one pond in 2021, each owner is close to every neighbor's runoff, every road culvert, and the association's next project. Ownership on Perkins Pond comes with a direct role in how the whole pond is kept.
For more on how Perkins Pond compares with the region's other lakes, see our Perkins Pond neighborhood page and our guide to Lake Sunapee.
If you own one of the original cottage lots on Perkins Pond, its value depends on its frontage, its size and how it compares with the handful of sales the town records each year. Pamela Perkins is a fourth-generation local broker who can tell you what this fall's contract says about your lot, or help you find frontage on the pond before the next one is listed. Get in Touch.
Discover additional insights, market perspectives, and curated real estate guidance.
With generational ties to Lake Sunapee and a record that defines the New Hampshire luxury market, Pam Perkins represents a level of knowledge, discretion, and performance that few can match. Her clients trust her not only because of what she’s sold — but because of what she knows.